Suspension riskHM-2 · Etsy's Creativity Standards

Mass-produced goods are prohibited in the Handmade category

What this rule means

Etsy does not allow mass-produced goods in the Handmade category. If a factory, wholesale supplier, or dropship service makes the item and you only resell it, the listing does not belong there. Items you make by hand, or with personal or computerized tools, are fine when the design is your own. The rule is about who makes the item and who designs it.

What Etsy says

Dropshipping and reselling are not allowed on Etsy, except in the specific cases outlined in this Help article, such as craft supplies.

Read Etsy's full Etsy's Creativity Standards

Why Etsy has this rule

Buyers come to Etsy for work made by a real person. If the same factory item shows up in dozens of shops, that promise falls apart and trust in the marketplace drops. Etsy wrote the Handmade rules to keep the category true to what buyers expect. The rule also protects makers. A seller who spends hours on each piece cannot compete on price with a catalog item that costs very little to buy in bulk. Etsy decides what counts as mass-produced, so a listing can be removed even when you believe it is handmade.

If you do work with a production partner on your own original designs, the rules allow it. You just have to disclose the partner on each affected listing.

Common mistakes

Listing an item that comes finished from a wholesale supplier or dropship service and calling it handmade.
Using the supplier's product photos, which often appear word for word on other marketplaces.
Offering dozens of identical colorways of a factory item with no studio or workspace photos.
Writing a listing description that never mentions your materials, tools, or how you make the item.
Using words like bulk, lot, or wholesale price in a listing title or description.
Promising a very short processing time on an item that you say is made to order by hand.
Using a production partner for your own designs and leaving the partner off the listing.
Assuming a small change, such as adding a name stamp to a factory blank, turns the item into your own work.

Examples

AllowedYou pour candles in your own studio and show the wax, wicks, and molds in your photos.
AllowedYou design a tote bag, have a production partner sew it, and disclose that partner on the listing.
AllowedYou cut and finish wooden signs with your own tools from a design you drew.
AllowedYou describe your process and tools in each listing and show the work in progress.
Not allowedYou list a phone case from an overseas catalog and ship it straight from the supplier.
Not allowedYou use the supplier's photos and the listing matches pages on other wholesale sites.
Not allowedYou offer fifty finished colorways of a stamped metal charm that you did not make.
Not allowedYou sell a bulk lot of factory-made party favors in the Handmade category.

How to stay compliant

Remove any listing where the item is sourced finished from a factory, wholesale supplier, or dropship service.
If you use a production partner to manufacture original designs, disclose that partner on each affected listing (Shop Manager > Listings > Edit > Production Partner).
Replace stock product photography with photos that show your own workspace, tools, or making process.
Rewrite listing descriptions to explain your design process and the tools you personally use.
If you use a CNC, laser cutter, or 3D printer, confirm and document that the design files are entirely your original creation — not downloaded templates.

Effort: high · 3-8 hours

If your suspension email cites this rule

Start by reading the email for the listing names and any wording about mass production or dropshipping. Then go through those listings one at a time and ask a plain question: who made this item, and who designed it? If you bought it finished, it does not belong in the Handmade category. If you made it, or you designed it and a partner produced it, note exactly which of those applies for each listing. Check your other listings too, since a pattern across your shop is easier for Etsy to spot than a single item.

If you plan to appeal, keep it honest and specific. Describe how you make or design the item, name any production partner, and say what you changed. Photos of your workspace, tools, and works in progress help more than general claims. Do not argue about the rule itself. Etsy makes the final decision, and an appeal does not guarantee the listing or shop returns.

Suspended over this rule?

Generate a complete, ready-to-submit Etsy appeal for this exact violation.

Generate your appeal letter

Common questions

Can I use a production partner and still be in the Handmade category?

Yes, if the design is yours and you disclose the partner on each affected listing. The partner makes your original design. A partner that ships a catalog item you did not design does not meet the rule.

Is dropshipping allowed on Etsy?

Not in the Handmade category. Items sourced finished from a factory, wholesale supplier, or dropship service are treated as mass-produced goods. Remove those listings or replace them with work you make or design.

Can I sell an item made with a laser cutter or 3D printer?

Yes, as long as the design is your own original work. Etsy allows items made with personal or computerized tools. It requires an original design, so a downloaded or purchased design does not count.

Will changing my photos fix a mass-produced listing?

No. Photos help show your process, but the item itself has to be made or designed by you. Swapping images on a factory item does not change what it is.

Do I need to prove that I made my items?

Etsy does not publish a fixed list of proof. Process photos, tool photos, design files, and a clear description of how you work are the strongest records to keep.